Allard Feddes, along with his colleagues, conducted a study in two Amsterdam neighborhoods to examine the relationship between citizens' perceived threat from refugees and their mental health. The research focused on two types of threat: symbolic threat (concerns about cultural values and norms) and realistic threat (concerns about competition for resources).

The study involved 280 participants, with a follow-up measurement after the settlement of refugees conducted in one neighborhood. The findings reveal a complex relationship between perceived threat and mental health:

  • Cross-sectional findings: Higher levels of both symbolic and realistic threat were associated with poorer mental health among citizens before refugee settlement.
  • Longitudinal findings: No increase in realistic or symbolic threat was observed after refugee settlement, but mental health worsened in citizens after the arrival of refugees.
  • Predictive findings: Higher threat perceptions before refugee settlement predicted poorer mental health after the settlement. This association was stronger than the reverse (poorer mental health predicting higher threat perceptions).

These results suggest that the perceived threat from refugees can negatively impact citizens' mental health, even when the actual threat does not increase. This highlights the importance of addressing citizens' concerns and perceptions to mitigate potential negative consequences of refugee settlement.

The researchers suggest that policymakers consider the existing levels of threat perception among citizens when developing and communicating refugee settlement policies. Open communication and addressing concerns about cultural differences and resource competition could help alleviate citizens' fears and promote better mental health outcomes in the long run.

Link to paper